Shogi (Sente) vs Chess (Black, Gote)

www.chess.com/bundles/web/images/image-default.445cb543.svg

Shogi Pieces Promotion (Only Available: Pawn, Lance, Knight, Silver, Bishop, Rook) : 7th~9th Ranks (Leave There Can Promote This Piece), Pawn, Lance, Knight, Silver >>> Gold; Bishop >>> Horse (龍馬), Rook >>> Dragon (龍王)
Chess Pawns Promotion: Only 9th Rank, Pawn >>> Queen/Knight If Been Captured Just Be Crazyhouse.
Nifu: Only Shogi Pawns Has This Restriction.
Perpetual check: Draw
Drops: Yes
Stalemate: Win (Jammed)
Impasse: No

If you can't see the image:
Chess King: 51
Chess Queen: 41
Chess Rooks: 11, 81
Chess Bishops: 31, 61
Chess Knights: 21, 71
Chess Pawns: 12, 22, 32, 42, 52, 62, 72, 82
VS A Shogi Normal Army.

How can you expect that anyone even understands what you're planning to do here?

This game is fair or unfair?

How would I know? You did a poor job in explaining what you even mean to do.

@goshujin He's describing some kind of variant game with shogi pieces on one side, and chess on the other.

I tried playing a game like this before and I remember it being awfully unbalanced

1

Oh ... I suppose the chess army won by a landslide, then. The queen alone is like a weapon of mass destruction by Shogi standards. Nowadays I even tend to think that her presence alone is a design flaw in Chess, as imo she concentrates way too much power in her person.

11

Yeah something like that. Depending on the rules you choose, either the shogi drop rule is way too powerful and swarms the chess side, or the queen and rooks just gobble up the slow-moving shogi army. My roommate and I 10 years ago played like a dozen games and both came to the conclusion that it was super broken. Maybe a more fair ruleset could be found, but we didn't bother to look.

1

@goshujin @LizardWizard If the queen with limit (Can only <=3)?